
In light of the upcoming Easter holiday for all my Christian friends, I thought I would share the history of Easter in a post. This isn't meant to offend our Christian friends, but it is my responsibility as a Jew to do all I can to prevent the worship of idols and the observance of pagan rituals - even if it's done in ignorance....especially if it's done in ignorance!
Easter History : Christian and Pagan Traditions Interwoven
The history of Easter reveals rich associations between the Christian faith and the seemingly unrelated practices of the early pagan religions. Easter history and traditions that we practice today evolved from pagan symbols, from the ancient goddess Ishtar to Easter eggs and the Easter bunny.
Easter, perhaps the most important of the Christian holidays, celebrates the Christ's resurrection from the dead following his death on Good Friday. . . a rebirth that is commemorated around the vernal equinox, historically a time of pagan celebration that coincides with the arrival of spring and symbolizes the arrival of light and the awakening of life around us.
Ostara, Goddess of Spring and the Dawn (Oestre / Eastre)
Easter is named for a Saxon goddess who was known by the names of Oestre or Eastre, and in Germany by the name of Ostara. She is a goddess of the dawn and the spring, and her name derives from words for dawn, the shining light arising from the east. Our words for the "female hormone" estrogen derives from her name.
Ostara was, of course, a fertility goddess. Bringing in the end of winter, with the days brighter and growing longer after the vernal equinox, Ostara had a passion for new life. Her presence was felt in the flowering of plants and the birth of babies, both animal and human. The rabbit (well known for its propensity for rapid reproduction) was her sacred animal.
Easter eggs and the Easter Bunny both featured in the spring festivals of Ostara, which were initially held during the feasts of the goddess Ishtar Inanna. Eggs are an obvious symbol of fertility, and the newborn chicks an adorable representation of new growth. Brightly colored eggs, chicks, and bunnies were all used at festival time to express appreciation for Ostara's gift of abundance.
History of Easter Eggs and Easter Candy
The history of Easter Eggs as a symbol of new life should come as no surprise. The notion that the Earth itself was hatched from an egg was once widespread and appears in creation stories ranging from Asian to Ireland.
Eggs, in ancient times in Northern Europe, were a potent symbol of fertility and often used in rituals to guarantee a woman's ability to bear children. To this day rural "grannywomen" (lay midwives/healers in the Appalachian mountains) still use eggs to predict, with uncanny accuracy, the sex of an unborn child by watching the rotation of an egg as it is suspended by a string over the abdomen of a pregnant woman.
Dyed eggs are given as gifts in many cultures. Decorated eggs bring with them a wish for the prosperity of the abundance during the coming year.
Folklore suggests that Easter egg hunts arose in Europe during "the Burning Times", when the rise of Christianity led to the shunning (and persecution) of the followers of the "Old Religion". Instead of giving the eggs as gifts the adults made a game of hiding them, gathering the children together and encouraging them to find the eggs. Some believe that the authorities seeking to find the "heathens" would follow or bribe the children to reveal where they found the eggs so that the property owner could be brought to justice.
Green Eggs.......and Ham?
The meat that is traditionally associated with Easter is ham. Though some might argue that ham is served at Easter since it is a "Christian" meat, (prohibited for others by the religious laws of Judaism and Islam) the origin probably lies in the early practices of the pagans of Northern Europe.
Having slaughtered and preserved the meat of their agricultural animals during the Blood Moon celebrations the previous autumn so they would have food throughout the winter months, they would celebrate the occasion by using up the last of the remaining cured meats.
In anticipation that the arrival of spring with its emerging plants and wildlife would provide them with fresh food in abundance, it was customary for many pagans to begin fasting at the time of the vernal equinox, clearing the "poisons" (and excess weight) produced by the heavier winter meals that had been stored in their bodies over the winter. Some have suggested that the purpose of this fasting may have been to create a sought-after state of "altered consciousness" in time for the spring festivals. One cannot but wonder if this practice of fasting might have been a forerunner of "giving up" foods during the Lenten season.
Chocolate Easter bunnies and eggs, marshmallow chicks in pastel colors, and candy of all sorts . . . these have pagan origins as well! To understand their association with religion we need to examine the meaning of food as a symbol.
The ancient belief that, by eating something we take on its characteristics formed the basis for the earliest "blessings" before meals (a way to honor the life that had been sacrificed so that we as humans could enjoy life) and, presumably, for the more recent Christian sacrament of communion as well.
Shaping candy Easter eggs and bunnies out of candy to celebrate the spring festival was, simply put, a way to celebrate the symbols of the goddess and the season, while laying claim to their strengths (vitality, growth, and fertility) for ourselves.
Feeling guilty about arriving late one spring, the Goddess Ostara saved the life of a poor bird whose wings had been frozen by the snow. She made him her pet or, as some versions have it, her lover. Filled with compassion for him since he could no longer fly (in some versions, it was because she wished to amuse a group of young children), Ostara turned him into a snow hare, named him Lepus, and gave him the gift of being able to run with incredible speed so he could protect himself from hunters. In remembrance of his earlier form as a bird, she also gave him the ability to lay eggs (in all the colors of the rainbow, no less), but only on one day out of each year.
Eventually Lepus managed to anger the goddess Ostara, and she cast him into the skies where he would remain as the constellation Lepus (The Hare) forever positioned under the feet of the constellation Orion (the Hunter). He was allowed to return to earth once each year, but only to give away his eggs to the children attending the Ostara festivals that were held each spring.
The Hare was sacred in many ancient traditions and was associated with the moon goddesses and the various deities of the hunt. In ancient times eating the Hare was prohibited except at Beltane (Celts) and the festival of Ostara (Anglo-Saxons), when a ritual hare-hunt would take place.
In many cultures rabbits, like eggs, were considered to be potent remedies for fertility problems. The ancient philosopher-physician Pliny the Elder prescribed rabbit meat as a cure for female sterility, and in some cultures the genitals of a hare were carried to avert barrenness.
Medieval Christians considered the hare to bring bad fortune, saying witches changed into rabbits in order to suck the cows dry. It was claimed that a witch could only be killed by a silver crucifix or a bullet when she appeared as a hare.
Given their "mad" leaping and boxing displays during mating season as well as their ability to produce up to 42 offspring each spring, it is understandable that they came to represent lust, sexuality, and excess in general. Medieval Christians considered the hare to be an evil omen, believing that witches changed into rabbits in order to suck the cows dry. It was claimed that a witch could only be killed by a silver crucifix or a bullet when she appeared as a hare.
In later Christian tradition the white Hare, when depicted at the Virgin Mary's feet, represents triumph over lust or the flesh. The rabbit's vigilance and speed came to represent the need to flee from sin and temptation and a reminder of the swift passage of life.
In later Christian tradition the white Hare, when depicted at the Virgin Mary's feet, represents triumph over lust or the flesh. The rabbit's vigilance and speed came to represent the need to flee from sin and temptation and a reminder of the swift passage of life.
And, finally, there is a sweet Christian legend about a young rabbit who, for three days, waited anxiously for his friend, Jesus, to return to the Garden of Gethsemane, not knowing what had become of him. Early on Easter morning, Jesus returned to His favorite garden and was welcomed the little rabbit. That evening when the disciples came into the garden to pray, still unaware of the resurrection, they found a clump of beautiful larkspurs, each blossom bearing the image of a rabbit in its center as a remembrance of the little creature's hope and faith.
Ishtar, Goddess of Love, and the First Resurrection
Ishtar, goddess of romance, procreation, and war in ancient Babylon, was also worshipped as the Sumerian goddess Inanna. One of the great goddesses, or "mother goddesses", stories of her descent to the Underworld and the resurrection that follows are contained in the oldest writings that have ever been discovered. . . the Babylonian creation myth Enuma Elish and the story of Gilgamesh. Scholars believed that they were based on the oral mythology of the region and were recorded about 2,100 B.C.E.
The most famous of the myths of Ishtar tell of her descent into the realm of the dead to rescue her young lover, Tammuz, a Vegetation god forced to live half the year in the Underworld. Ishtar approached the gates of the Underworld, which was ruled by her twin sister Eresh-kigel, the goddess of death and infertility. She was refused admission.
Similar to the Greek myths of Demeter and Persephone that came later, during Ishtar's absence the earth grew barren since all acts of procreation ceased while she was away. Ishtar screamed and ranted that she would break down the gates and release all of the dead to overwhelm the world and compete with the living for the remaining food unless she was allowed to enter and plead her case with her twin.
Needless to say, she won admission. But the guard, following standard protocol, refused to let her pass through the first gate unless she removed her crown. At the next gate, she had to remove her earrings, then her necklace at the next, removing her garments and proud finery until she stood humbled and naked after passing through the seventh (and last) gate.
In one version, she was held captive and died but was brought back to life when her servant sprinkled her with the "water of life". In the more widely known version of the myth, Ishtar's request was granted and she regained all of her attire and possessions as she slowly re-emerged through the gates of darkness.
Upon her return, Tammuz and the earth returned to life. Annual celebrations of this "Day of Joy", were held each year around the time of the vernal equinox. These celebrations became the forerunners of the Ostara festivals that welcomed Oestre and the arrival of spring.
Easter eggs, the Easter Bunny, the dawn that arrives with resurrection of life, and the celebration of spring all serve to remind us of the cycle of rebirth and the need for renewal in our lives. In the history of Easter, Christian and pagan traditions are gracefully interwoven.



52 comments:
we don't do easter, but will recognize the resurrection three days after passover next month!
peaceful purim to you and yours, yehudi.
How do you feel about marshmallow peeps? Man, them things are good!!! :)
On a more serious note -- what are pagan traditions? Are they not a bending or twisting of something natural and good? Did God not create everything and say that it was good? Is there anything in nature that is evil or is it only the view of man that makes things good or bad? If Easter has its history in pagan ritual and pagan tradition does that mean that is what the day was meant for by nature or by God? Weren't all days created holy to start with? Isn't every day the day that the LORD hath made in which we should rejoice and be glad? I don't give any day over to the pagans but rather take every day as a day to praise God and rejoice and be glad. In this vein I will decorate eggs with my girls as a way to have a fun event as a family and they will eat chocolate bunnies and be thankful and joyful for chocolate and I will thank God for coming to earth to live and die for my sin. And I will rejoice at the thought of his rising from the death as the firstfruit of victory over sin and death. I will do this in every day which will, by constraint of the word every, include what is known as Easter Sunday. Just my two cents worth - take it or leave it. Shabbat shalom my friend!!! Please don't take this as combative but rather as a shift of thinking. Paganism does not own any day of the year but rather they all belong to God and are holy. I will not allow pagans a claim on any day because all days were made to rejoice and be glad in.
Yehudi: just something I noticed while reading your post: you used Jesus's Greek name which means "our savior", the C-name, if you will. This is offensive in nature to you and I because we do not consider Jesus to have been our savior in any way, shape or form.
As you can tell, I'm blogging on Shabbat and I apologize in advance. I'd also like to commend you for taking up the fight against the pageanism which many of our Christian friends practice inadvertantly.
Jason, I have to agree with your perspective 100%. Well said, my friend. I would have countered with the same thing if someone told me that Hanukkah had pagan influences, for example. I hope that you and your family have a fantastic Easter!
Eitan, I apologize for (1)blogging on Shabbat as well, and (2) using the "C" word. I wasn't the author of this post...if I was, I wouldn't have used it. What are your plans for Pesach, my friend?
So you do feel good about marshmallow peeps then? :)
I don't feel good about them at all.....but I'll share a little secret.....[whisper]..I love solid milk chocolate bunnies!
We do not celebrate Easter in the way you describe. No bunnies or eggs here. We do use the day to commemorate the resurrection of our Christ.
I say use because it is the day set aside on the calender and it is a time of year when many non believers are suddenly thinking of religion.
we refer to it as Resurrection Day, not Easter.
A lot of Christians do not understand the paganisms of Easter traditions which is very sad. However, many of us are aware of this and do not participate.
Great article, may I direct some Christian friends here? or would you prefer I copy it and send it along with you as the source, but without a link?
Feel free to send your friends to my blog, JM! They're welcome here anytime.
I agree, JM! We celebrate Resurrection Sunday, and I prefer lamb as a bow to the Lamb WHO died for my sins!
The rcs have wrecked alot of havok(my Mother was rc, so don't scream at me)in their attempt to bring in and entice pagans. I believe that was foolish.
G*D doesn't need any help drawing the lost, HE can do it just fine, by HIMSELF!
Thanks for posting this Yehudi, very factual and to the point!
tmw
BTW-The after ishtar specials will yield a wealth of chocolate bunnies to keep in the freezer for blue days! LOL!
I must confess...I do eat the chocolate bunnies!!!!
Guys, why don't we not desecrate shabbat before we rail against paganism?
I find it amusing that Christians try to 'kasher' Easter and take out the paganism when their faith at root is the worship of a savviour man-god almost identical to Mithras, Zoroaster, Dionysus, Osiris or Isis. Wrap it in a tallis, put a kippah on it, dunk it in a mikveh and put on OU stamp on it, but if it believes in Jesus Cripes as Lord and Saviour, it ain't kosher.
Shavuah Tov!
i don't celebrate "easter" - it is expressly forbidden in the confines of the bible. refer to bowing to the east at sunrise...then get on your knees and apologize...our family tries to honor the Lord each and every day.
as far as marshmallow peeps - put one on a piece of waxed paper in the microwave for about fifteen seconds - STAINED GLASS PEEP BLOB!
ff - the best day to buy chocolate bunnies? the day AFTER easter when they're 75% off~! economics, my friend, economics.
b.k. Yeshua kept to the law, salvation is of the jew and christians recognize that fact. please, no ten page diatribes.
WHERE'S MY AVATAR?!?
BK -- One of these days you'll realize that God made the Sabbath for man and not man for the Sabbath.
and you, Jason will one day realize that Judaism is inheritantly different from Christianity and that we will keep to our teachings without your interference.
Nanc, it's only "Debora" who goes on 3-page diatribes over at B.K.'s but I need to let you know B.K., a high school student knows more about both your religion and ours than you in your infinite wisdom.
Oh, and Yehudi, Jason is way off if you ask any practicing Jew so I have no idea why you would agree with him.
Eitan -- what am I way off about?
Eitan, it is Jason's perogative to observe Easter or not, and if he chooses to; then he is free to determine how he observes it..I simply appreciated how he chooses to separate the pagan influences from his method of observance. Jason is my friend, and I love that he is a friend of the Jewish people, a friend of Israel, and he serves the G-d of Israel. He's ok in my book!
ok Jason I love peeps! they're my favorite!
Shalom
Karin
Guys, you're all OK in my books. Even if you guys are the biggest pagn-worshipping, saviour-god adoring idol worshipped (Just Kidding), I'll still love you. ;)
FF- I'm still not sure what that comment about the shabbat means? G-d said to keep it and JC said that you don't have to. You take JC- I'll take G-d.
Nanc- Jesus said things that both opposed and affirmed the laws. He desecrated the shabbat, broke fasts, violated kashrut and didn't wash his hands. Christianity is essentially repackaged pagan myths in a Jewish setting.
BK -- What the comment about the Sabbath means is that the Sabbath was not given to man as a responsibility but rather as a gift. Just as God rested from His work on the seventh day of creation so we need to take a rest from our work on the seventh day as well. God certainly did not NEED a rest but rather He gave us a wonderful example and the gift of rest. He never meant for man to work at getting the checklist right and doing or not doing certain things on the Sabbath. He simply wanted man to make sure that he was taking a rest during the week and focusing on their relationship with the Creator. And just for the record -- you are OK in my book as well and will be welcome at our campfire anytime.
Daniel and Karin -- thank you so much for your friendship and love. You guys are true friends.
Yeshua fulfilled the law, b.k.
Jason, the laws of Shabbat are some of the most complex laws in Judaism. there are 39 melachot, commonly translated as labours, which are forbidden on Shabbat, derived from the labours involved in building the Tabernacle since G-d rested from creating and the tabernacle was a microcosm of the universe. Shabbat is hardly a nice suggestion and it has nothing to do with manual labour as it is permissible to carry your sofa up and down the stairs but not to carry a sheet of paper into an area without an eiruv.
The word melachah is rarely used in scripture outside of the context of Shabbat and holiday restrictions. The only other repeated use of the word is in the discussion of the building of the sanctuary and its vessels in the wilderness. Exodus Ch. 31, 35-38. Notably, the Shabbat restrictions are reiterated during this discussion (Ex. 31:13), thus we can infer that the work of creating the sanctuary had to be stopped for Shabbat. From this, the rabbis concluded that the work prohibited on the Sabbath is the same as the work of creating the sanctuary. They found 39 categories of forbidden acts, all of which are types of work that were needed to build the sanctuary:
Sowing
Plowing
Reaping
Binding sheaves
Threshing
Winnowing
Selecting
Grinding
Sifting
Kneading
Baking
Shearing wool
Washing wool
Beating wool
Dyeing wool
Spinning
Weaving
Making two loops
Weaving two threads
Separating two threads
Tying
Untying
Sewing two stitches
Tearing
Trapping
Slaughtering
Flaying
Salting meat
Curing hide
Scraping hide
Cutting hide up
Writing two letters
Erasing two letters
Building
Tearing a building down
Extinguishing a fire
Kindling a fire
Hitting with a hammer
Taking an object from the private domain to the public, or transporting an object in the public domain.
(Mishnah Shabbat, 7:2)
Shabbat is an obligation incumbent on every singly Jew. It is not just a nice idea. The penalty for shabbat desecration is death by stoning and karet, spiritual excision in the World to Come. It is the most mentionned mitzvah in the Torah and the only one which the Prophets specifically chide the Jews for not keeping.
Stop reading the King James Bible and start studying the Torah (Oral and Written)!
Nanc: Not so fast. Jesus violated the laws of Kashrut, declaring all foods to be 'clean' (Mark 7:18-19, Matthew 15:11, Matthew 6:25). Jesus also changed the Torah's laws regarding divorce. Compare Deut 24:1 with Matt 19:9 or Mark 10:3-4,11. His disciples also picked ears of corn on Shabbat which desecrates it (Mark 2:23). He also did not wash his hands and refused to fast on various Jewish fast days. He was hardly sinless.
BK, you are taking verses out of context, again. Yeshua did NOT make all foods clean, for if that were the case, then Rabbi Sha'ul would not have remained a Pharisee and Torah-observant until he died. Also, Yeshua said in Matt ch 5:17-19, "Don't think that I have come to abolish the Torah or the Prophets. I have not come to abolish, but to complete. Yes indeed! I tell you that until Heaven and Earth pass away, not so much as a yud or a stroke will pass from the Torah-not until everything that must happen has happened. So whoever disobeys the least of these mitzvot and teaches others to do so will be called least in the Kingdom of Heaven. But whoever obeys them and so teaches will be called great in the Kingdom of Heaven."
Regarding divorce, he issued a more strict ruling, and concerning desecrating Shabbat, he simply never did. BK, there are halachic rulings that bring us closer to the heart of God, but there are also halachic rulings that make it more difficult to enter into an intimate relationship with Him. I spent time this last weekend reading through Yehudi's blog and I loved his book that he wrote, "Hineni!" I thought, "How ironic that a non-believing Jew could write to the rest of us about intimacy with God, when rabbinical Judaism all but prevents intimacy! Take the time to read the Brit Chadashah yourself...don't just cut and paste from an anti-missionary website. Read it in Hebrew, (I won't have a King James bible in my home), and ask God to open your eyes of understanding....and He will my friend. Have a blessed seder, and I look forward to our discussions once again!
Oh, proof that Rav Sha'ul was a Pharisee, please read Acts 26:4-8.
Paul was a Kopher, at best, and quoting from Christian scriptures doesnt really convince Jews of anything.
For deeper study, I use a Hebrew-English Interlinear...does that count?
Hope you had a fun Purim!
tmw
BDJ- First of all, how dare you come to Daniel's blog and insinuate that he is a non-believing Jew. That is lashon harah and the sin is magnified infinately since you slandered him before goyyim. You are a min, an apikorous and a kofer, who has no share in the World to Come.
Jesus made rather ambiguous statements about the mitzvot. Sometimes he opposed them and sometimes he supported them.
Paul was the source of opposition to Jewish Law. He called the Torah a curse (Galatians 3:13, 24-25, Romans 10:4, Hebrews 8:13, Galatians 2:21) and claimed that Jesus completed it. Paul's theology was and is heretical.
Why would I read the Christian Bible in Hebrew when it was written in Greek, as almost all modern scholars believe? It is testimony to the complete antipathy that the Jews felt towards Jesus (if he even existed) that they felt it unnecessary to even preserve one Hebrew manuscript of the NT. It was originally written in Greek and there are more than 30 000 variation in the text. It is completely unreliable.
There is no point of quoting Christian scriptures, as KL said, because we do not accept. You may as well quote from the Book of Mormon or Harry Potter, two other great pieces of fiction.
Merry Easter.
If you condemn the New Testament for being first written in Greek then why do you not condemn the oral Torah for being first written in Arabic?
Ummmmm.... because it wasn't. Have you ever even opened a Gemara? The Mishna was written in Hebrew and the Talmud in Aramaic. This is because Aramaic was the lingua franca of the Jews. The NT was written in Greek because the Jews saw right through its lies and falsehoods so it was directed at the goyyim who spoke Greek.
Nice cop out. Concentrate on the trivial.
My fault, I meant Aramaic. Just as many Jews spoke Aramaic at the time of the writing of the Talmud many Jews spoke Greek at the time of the writing of the New Testament as the writers were Jews. Christianity is born of Jewish descent and that is one of the reasons that true Christians are grateful to the Jewish people and have a love for them. There are other reasons as well but this is one of them.
b.k. - if your ox falls into a ditch on sabbath, will you rescue it?
You didn't understand what I meant...I implied that it was ironic that a non-Messianic Jew could write a book about intimacy with God, when rabbinical Judaism doesn't make that endeavor easy, to say the least. I meant no offense to Daniel or anyone else here.
God's Law is highest, not the teaching and tradition of men (rabbi, pastor, etc.)! It is of the self-righteous, religious men that Yeshua spoke of when He had the following exchange:
5 The Pharisees and the scribes asked Him, "Why do Your disciples not walk according to the tradition of the elders, but eat their bread with impure hands?"
6 And He said to them, "Rightly did Isaiah prophesy of you hypocrites, as it is written:
'THIS PEOPLE HONORS ME WITH THEIR LIPS,
BUT THEIR HEART IS FAR AWAY FROM ME.
7 'BUT IN VAIN DO THEY WORSHIP ME,
TEACHING AS DOCTRINES THE PRECEPTS OF MEN.'
8 "Neglecting the commandment of God, you hold to the tradition of men." - Mark 7:5-8
BTW, no offense taken, Daniel. As a Christian who is beginning to understand the Jewish roots of my faith, I appreciate the truth you speak as a Jew to Christians in this post. I hope you take no offense in me posting my understanding and belief above.
Thank you for posting the truth about Easter... for those who practice this pagan holiday after knowing better, it is a shame as we are held to account according to what we know.
Hope you had a wonderfur Purim! I did... for the first time.
BK-I use a Greek-English Interlinear for study of the newer testament. Sorry I didn't make myself clear.
And Paul did admonish the gentile Christians to remember the roots of Christianity AND treat the Jews as the 'natural branches', with respect and appreciation. "To the Jew first..."
Good morning, G*D bless and Maranatha!
tmw
Christianity is not a succesor or child of Judaism, its a combination of Paganism and Monotheism. While theologically we laughed at Christianity temporaly for centuries Christians of all stripes were strong and a danger for that reason. But we have never viewed it as anything but a false religion. We have never accepted your beliefs and we never will.
KL -- like it or not, believe it or not -- CHRISTIANITY WAS BORN OUT OF JUDAISM AND STARTED BY JEWS. For that fact we are eternally grateful and praise and thank God for the Jewish people.
Bar,
G-d chose to use Greek for the new covenant for the simple fact that we gentiles were now to be partakers also. Part of the reason why Christianity spread so fast was that we were finally given the Scriptures and made to understand it was for the Greek and the Jew. I am so thankful for the first Christians who shared this with us...they were Jews.
BK, thank you for punching BDJ in the throat for me...we just set up a wireless system for our computer, and it went down yesterday afternoon. UGH!
BDJ, I don't take offense to what you said because you clarified yourself...but I do take issue with you coming to my blog and trying to missionize my Jewish brothers. You're welcome to believe what you want, but keep it on your blog. Don't bring it here.
BK&KL, I see Christianity as having the most in common with Judaism. I've heard that Islam is the most related to Judaism, but I reject that out of hand. Islam is the antithesis of Judaism...we don't kill children and non-combatants...we don't preach death and destruction.
That said, there should be a very clear line of delineation between Judaism and Christianity. "Tall fences make good neighbors," they say. I am all for open dialogue and recognizing who our friends are, and who our friends aren't. I forgot the point I was trying to make....ugh. I guess that's what happens when you get old!
The Christian Bible is not a completion of the Torah but in fact stands in stark opposition to it. The Torah's path for salvation is to fear G-d and to keep His mitzvot while according to Christianity, one must simply accept JC. All rabbinic authorities hold that such a belief is idolatry to Jews and therefore punishable by karet (spiritual excision in the World to Come and death by heaven), while many agree that it is permissible for non-Jews. Jews are forbidden from entering churches or from doing business with Christians before their festivals as they are idolatrous. On the other hand, all rabbinic authorities agree that Islam is not idolatry and a Jew can enter into a mosque. Islam is much closer religious to Judaism in terms of perception of G-d while Christianity is closer in terms of values. There are Judea-Christian values but no Judeo-Christian faith.
And G-d's mitzvot, while derided by Christians, are intended to bring us closer to Him. BDJ, like I suspected, you surely never had a Jewish education or saw real Jewish passion. That explains your conversion as it is in Christianity that you unfortunately found passion.
BK -- "The Christian Bible is not a completion of the Torah but in fact stands in stark opposition to it. The Torah's path for salvation is to fear G-d and to keep His mitzvot while according to Christianity, one must simply accept JC."
This here is simply not true. To fear God and keep His commands is what Christianity is all about.
Acts 10:34+35
" 34Then Peter began to speak: "I now realize how true it is that God does not show favoritism 35but accepts men from every nation who fear him and do what is right."
So what is more important: faith or works? I htought that Christians hold that faith is the key.
Sorry for this long quote from James;
[15] If a brother or sister be naked, and destitute of daily food,
[16] And one of you say unto them, Depart in peace, be ye warmed and filled; notwithstanding ye give them not those things which are needful to the body; what doth it profit?
[17] Even so faith, if it hath not works, is dead, being alone.
[18] Yea, a man may say, Thou hast faith, and I have works: shew me thy faith without thy works, and I will shew thee my faith by my works.
[19] Thou believest that there is one God; thou doest well: the devils also believe, and tremble.
[20] But wilt thou know, O vain man, that faith without works is dead?
[21] Was not Abraham our father justified by works, when he had offered Isaac his son upon the altar?
[22] Seest thou how faith wrought with his works, and by works was faith made perfect?
[23] And the scripture was fulfilled which saith, Abraham believed God, and it was imputed unto him for righteousness: and he was called the Friend of God.
[24] Ye see then how that by works a man is justified, and not by faith only.
[25] Likewise also was not Rahab the harlot justified by works, when she had received the messengers, and had sent them out another way?
[26] For as the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without works is dead also.
In other words, faith is just words without something to prove it's existence.
I would never trust someone who said they were a Christian if they lived like the world with no change.
tmw
The Merry Widow answered exactly as I would have. Many "christians" live very loose lives and show no action to back up their boastings about how much faith they have. To be quite honest, there is a large number of "christians" who treat church or bible study as much more of a social club and spend most of their time thinking about themselves or their friends and very little time worshipping God and studying or learning. There's a great deal more of people who live their lives to act good on sundays and live completely different the rest of the week.
In Romans it says, "because by the works of the Law no flesh will be justified in His sight . . . " (Rom. 3:20), and "for we maintain that a man is justified by faith apart from works of the Law," (Rom. 3:28), and "For what does the Scripture say? ‘And Abraham believed God, and it was reckoned to him as righteousness'" (Rom. 4:3), and "Therefore, having been justified by faith . . . " (Rom. 5:1), and "But to the one who does not work, but believes in Him who justifies the ungodly, his faith is reckoned as righteousness" (Rom. 4:5).
Eph. 2:8-10, "For by grace you have been saved through faith; and that not of yourselves, it is the gift of God; not as a result of works, that no one should boast. For we are His workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand, that we should walk in them."
Contradictions?
There is a close relationship between faith and works. It's a splitting of hairs. On one hand I would boldly proclaim that it is my faith in God and His plan that has saved me. On the other hand I would argue that if you do not have good works then it is surely a sign that you do not have faith. It is the faith that saves but it is the good works that are the evidence of the faith. Additionally the good works is the purpose that we were created for and that we were meant, by God, to do. The works do not save us because we do not have the ability to earn salvation but rather we have faith enough to accept the free gift of salvation that God has offered to us which will then result in us doing the good works that He planned for us to do. As you can see -- the two are very closely intertwined.
b.k. our works are a result of our salvation, not the other way around. hairsplitting is sometimes required.
if i say i am saved and there is no fruit then am i truly saved?
think motive. christians are to have no motive to their works. it is futile and an insult to Yahweh to think we could top what He's done for us.
it is akin to saying, "sorry, God, but what Yeshua did on the cross was just not enough - i'm going to make it more worthwhile."
how insulting!
tmw - there is no need for you to apoligize for the gospel! none.
no offense, but this whole thing is silly. No Christian WORSHIPS the Easter bunny or peeps or eggs or flowers or chocolate.
A DAY has been selected honoring new life (the resurrection) in the Spring, when new life abounds (flowers and new green leaves on trees are not pagan).
We have no idea the exact day Christ was born, but we celebrate Christmas on A DAY, so we have a day to commemorate and spend with loved ones the day that formed our faith and our futures. z
yehudi01,
thanks for this informative post. I found it very insightful. I think some changes are in store for my family next year.
Also, thank you for the kind words on BK's blog. I know they weren't ihtended just for me, but it's nice to have a place to come and learn more.
Post a Comment